10-29-2026, 12:31 PM
(10-29-2026, 12:19 PM)b789 Wrote: @KHarHar, this IAS decision is even more risible than expected. Quite frankly, it is a textbook example of why the IAS has earned its reputation as a kangaroo court and why its supposed independence is treated with such scepticism. When an adjudicator attributes arguments to an appellant that were never made, ignores the arguments that actually were made, parrots operator-friendly boilerplate and then produces a predetermined-looking rejection, the process appears not merely incompetent but fundamentally compromised and corrupt in effect.
It reads like the adjudicator is a feckwit of the first order and has pasted substantial chunks of a stock rejection template into your case without even checking whether the supposed arguments were ever made.
You did not argue that the £100 was disproportionate, that there was no loss or legitimate interest, that Beavis somehow invalidated the charge, that the NtK was served late, or that a grace period entitled the driver to free parking. Yet the adjudicator solemnly "determines" all of those points anyway. That alone tells you how much genuine consideration appears to have been given to your actual appeal.
Meanwhile, the issues you did raise are largely evaded. There is no proper engagement with Jopson v Homeguard and the clear distinction between ordinary parking and genuine loading/unloading of heavy furniture. Instead, the adjudicator parrots the private parking industry's own definition of "parked" as though an IPC/BPA trade code somehow outranks or neutralises the reasoning of a Circuit Judge on appeal. It does not.
The decision is equally evasive on the signage. PCM's signs do not say "No Loading", "No Unloading" or "No Stopping". The argument was never that the driver was entitled to some undefined period of free parking. The argument was that PCM is trying to convert the absence of an express loading exemption into an express contractual prohibition on loading. The adjudicator simply avoids that point.
The landowner-authority issue has simply been ignored. PCM expressly relied upon a landowner agreement which it refused to disclose to the appellant, while inviting the IAS to inspect it privately. The rebuttal specifically challenged that approach and relied upon the PPSCoP requirement concerning arrangements and exemptions for loading/unloading and deliveries.
The adjudicator's decision contains no meaningful reference to any of that. There is no finding on the scope of PCM's authority, no consideration of the loading/unloading provisions, no explanation of whether the undisclosed contract was reviewed, and no attempt to address the procedural unfairness of relying upon evidence withheld from the appellant. The point was not answered; it was simply omitted.
That is precisely why the IAS has such a dismal reputation. Whether this adjudicator is genuinely legally trained or not, this decision does nothing to demonstrate it. It has the appearance of a predetermined, template-driven rejection designed to preserve the operator's charge rather than engage with the actual law and evidence. I would describe the reasoning as mendacious in effect and wholly lacking in credibility, because it attributes arguments to you that you never made while avoiding the ones you actually did.
The PoFA paragraph is particularly pathetic. The adjudicator states, without analysis, that "the Operator has complied with the relevant provisions of POFA 2012" and then immediately talks only about whether the NtK was received after the second working day.
That bears almost no relationship to the actual Schedule 4 issue. PoFA compliance is not determined merely by whether an NtK arrived within a particular timeframe. There are multiple mandatory statutory requirements which must be satisfied before keeper liability can arise, yet the adjudicator identifies none of them, analyses none of them and explains none of them.
It reads as though another stock paragraph has simply been inserted into the decision. A supposedly legally qualified adjudicator should know that a bare assertion of "PoFA compliance" is not a substitute for examining the statutory conditions which create keeper liability.
The only useful sentence in the whole decision is the adjudicator's admission that the result is not legally binding on you.
So what happens next? Most likely you will receive the usual debt-collector rubbish first. File it and ignore it. They have no powers and cannot determine liability.
If you receive a genuine Letter of Claim/Letter Before Claim from PCM or its solicitors, do not use their enclosed Reply Form. Respond by email, keep a complete copy of what you send, and deal with the issues properly in your own words. The stock forms can go in the bin.
If PCM eventually issues a County Court claim, that is when the matter finally reaches a proper judicial forum. There, PCM will not be able to hide behind an IAS adjudicator saying they have privately looked at a document that you were never allowed to see. If they rely upon the landowner agreement, they will have to produce it and you will be entitled to scrutinise and challenge it properly.
Your trip in November should not be a problem provided somebody is checking your post and you monitor your email. The only things that must never be ignored are a genuine Letter of Claim and, obviously, an actual County Court claim.
For now, keep everything: the original appeal, PCM's prima facie case, your rebuttal, the IAS decision and all the exhibits. This decision may actually be useful later because its obvious template contamination and failure to engage with the real issues considerably diminish whatever persuasive weight PCM might try to attach to it in court.
Thank you very much - I am also absolutely astounded. Until 3/4s of the way through, I was genuinely wondering whether they had responded to the wrong case. Totally irrelevant sections have been copy-pasted in.
It is genuinely wild that such a system is allowed to operate and prey on people while pretending to be independent. Truly shocking. Truly kafkaesque when legitimate arguments are ignored and contrived processes like this are put in place to pantomime the illusion of legal process.
Thank you for the clarity on the process. I’ll continue saving away and filing things. While I hope it doesn’t come to it, I feel confident now ok dusting off my old moot court days and defending my position should it come to that. I will let you know if a letter before claim comes my way.
Many thanks.

