Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
PCN - received while vehicle was being loaded for 10 minutes.
#18
(09-24-2026, 04:02 PM)b789 Wrote: That's normal for them and all other IPC operators. Just wait for the pretend solicitor that is adjudicating to come back with their decision.

Good morning b789!

I have received my response from the IAS and they have predictably dismissed my appeal. Their response back is infuriating, and doesn’t actually contend with any of the salient issues of our arguments. They rely on the private code of conduct for their definition of parking, and ignore most of our case law.

Please see below their response:

“The Appellant should understand that the Adjudicator is not in a position to give legal advice to either of the parties, but they are entitled to seek their own independent legal advice. The Adjudicator's role is to consider whether or not the parking charge has a basis in law and was properly issued in the circumstances of each individual case. In all Appeals the Adjudicator is bound by the relevant law applicable at the time and is only able to consider legal challenges and not factual mistakes nor extenuating or mitigating circumstances. Throughout this appeal the Operator has had the opportunity to consider all points raised and could have conceded the appeal at any stage. The Adjudicator who deals with this Appeal is legally qualified and each case is dealt with according to their understanding of the law as it applies, and the legal principles involved. A decision by an Adjudicator is not legally binding on an Appellant who is entitled to seek their own legal advice if they so wish.

In all Appeals the burden of proof is the civil one whereby the party asserting a fact or submission has to establish that matter on the balance of probabilities. If the parking operator fails to establish that a Parking Charge Notice was properly issued in accordance with the law, then it is likely that an Appeal will be allowed. If the parking operator does establish that a Parking Charge Notice was properly and legally issued, then the burden shifts to the Appellant to establish that the notice was improperly or unlawfully issued and if the Appellant proves those matters on the balance of probabilities, then it is likely that the Appeal will be allowed. However, the Appeal will be dismissed if the Appellant fails to establish those matters on the balance of probabilities. The responsibility is at all times on the parties to provide the Adjudicator with the evidential basis upon which to make a decision.

The signs offer the terms for parking. By remaining parked on land managed by the Operator, having had notice of the terms, the driver agrees to them. In consideration for entering the site they agree to have a valid authorisation by correctly registering their vehicle for a permit or pay the charge. In this way they have entered into a contract with the Operator and agreed to be bound by the advertised terms.

The Appellant contends that the Parking Charge should not have been issued and implies that the signage is not prominent or as clear as the operator suggests. Although the operator's prima facie case includes a description, which can include a site map, once an Appellant raises an issue with the signage on site, the operator cannot simply rely on the description. The description is simply an indication as to where the signage should have been located when the operator took over the site. It is not always an accurate representation of the current state of the signage on site. There is an ‘inequality of arms' between the operator and the Appellant, and as such it is not unreasonable for the operator to counter the Appellant's contention by the submission of photographic evidence of the site signage in situ, which will show that the signage is prominent and clear, or not, as the case may be.

I am satisfied that the signs are clear, numerous and unequivocal. This is evidenced by the Operator's exhibits and images. The Appellant has made numerous assertions but has not provided sufficient evidence corrobarating their claims.

Even if I accept the Appellant's claims, I am unable to allow the appeal on this basis. The terms are clear. If the driver did not have a valid authorisation they have few options. They could contact the Operator and request temporary permission to park. Alternatively, they could park elsewhere. Otherwise. they could remain parked and agree to pay the charge.

The terms and conditions of parking at this location are such that drivers must have a valid authorisation for their vehicle which entitles them to park there. In the evidence provided to me it is clear that there was no such authorisation and therefore that a Parking Charge Notice was lawfully issued. It is the driver's responsibility to ensure that they have authorisation that conforms with the terms and conditions of the parking operator's signage displayed at this site. The driver should also appreciate that only the parking operator should be consulted and relied upon if there are any problems arising.

Some definitions of ‘parking' refer to leaving the vehicle. Leave in this sense does not mean to walk away from the vehicle. It means to allow or cause to remain. This definition does not mean that a driver should be permitted to remain for an unspecified period of time and not be parked, then at some point not identified, they would become parked. Clearly parking is a question of fact not degree. One cannot become parked after the passage of an indeterminate period of time. The code of practice defines parked as “being stationary other than in the course of driving.” This incorporates the position of the Appellant's vehicle.

The Appellant should note that the grace period is a period of ten minutes at the end of a permitted period of parking. Consequently, it does not apply at the start of the parking event. The driver is entitled to a reasonable time to read the terms and comply with the requirements. However, the time allowed is for this purpose only and the driver must read the terms and attempt to comply immediately. If the driver chooses not to read the sign or uses the time for their own purpose, as here, leaves the site the period is at an end and they are deemed to have accepted the terms of parking by their actions. If they cannot comply they must leave. There is no set time limit I must apply, although there are guidelines and the Operator may have a policy not to charge within a set time. The longer the vehicle is on site the less likely it is to be reasonable. The consideration and grace period cannot be considered as 'free 'parking time' either separately or combined. The Appellant provides no evidence as to why the time they took was reasonable.

The Appellant references the case of Beavis, but has not appreciated that when the Supreme Court creates a legal principle it is not restricted to the facts of the case which gave rise to the principle.

No obstruction, no loss, no legitimate interest & Beavis
The identification, enforcement of breaches of the terms and conditions of parking require a significant amount of costs and logistics on the part of the Land Owner. The matter is of such importance to the Land Owner that they have delegated these responsibilities to the Operator at cost to themselves. This is regardless as to whether an obstruction was caused or not.

The Appellant implies the amount is disproportionate and does not serve a legitimate interest. There is clearly a legitimate interest in preventing drivers from parking in breach of the terms and conditions at the site. The amount is standard. It is also that which the driver agreed to pay when entering and then parking on the site.

Turning to the charge of £100. It is always £100. However, whilst the amount does not change the Operator agrees to accept less than this if paid within a specified time frame. Once the time frame has elapsed, as it clearly will with an appeal, that option is no longer available to the Appellant. The Operator is simply notifying the Appellant. If the Operator said nothing and the Appellant subsequently discovered they had to pay the £100 they would be rightly aggrieved they had not been warned.

The Operator has complied with the relevant provisions of POFA 2012. The Notice to Keeper is considered in time unless there is evidence beyond the Appellant's mere assertion that it was received after the second working day. In the absence of such evidence I cannot consider the matter further.

The Appellant has my sympathy, but the guidance to the appeal is clear that I may only consider legal issues not extenuating circumstances. The Operator has this discretion, and they exercised it in the Appellant's favour, by offering the reduced payment. Having rejected this offer the Appellant is now liable to pay the full charge.“


What happens now? I assume I get a number of debt collection letters which I will ignore, and then a letter from a legal firm? I’m unsure as to how the process goes. I will be going away for a number of weeks in November - I’m assuming the process from now will be quite slow, but will this be an issue as I won’t be contactable? Apologies for the dump of questions that aren’t exactly legal in nature - I’m just aware that you have seen so many of these processes play out start to finish.

Again, many thanks for your help and eager to get your thoughts on this.


Messages In This Thread
RE: PCN - received while vehicle was being loaded for 10 minutes. - by KHarHar - 10-29-2026, 10:31 AM

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Instant notice to keeper, no first letter PCN received? cringepcnskekw 9 660 11-14-2026, 10:08 PM
Last Post: cringepcnskekw
  Received POC from BWLegal on behalf of UK CPM Ltd Barbudaprince 46 9,560 11-07-2026, 08:01 PM
Last Post: Barbudaprince
  Claim form received from two alleged contraventions 3 years ago - SMART PARKING JoeBloggs90 21 4,873 10-13-2026, 02:13 PM
Last Post: b789
  Received a PCN whilst outside of the country JParker 5 1,024 09-29-2026, 10:53 AM
Last Post: b789
  Euro Car Parks – Paid Monthly Permit / Vehicle Swap Glitch – Morrisons Bangor Hondaenthusiast 1 319 09-21-2026, 06:20 PM
Last Post: b789
  Received a HM Claim form, not sure what to do! Dreamscape 4 961 08-25-2026, 07:27 PM
Last Post: Dreamscape
  LPS Ltd - PCN - Private Access Road - Delivering On Site & Vehicle Breakdown TheParkingmeister 27 8,606 05-26-2026, 04:32 PM
Last Post: b789
  UKPC PCN - Friern Barnet Retail Park - Vehicle was parked in registered users only merweetntr 9 3,730 03-04-2026, 04:19 PM
Last Post: b789
  Parked outside marked bay, PCM. 3 LOC/LBC Received Vivd23 1 1,025 02-28-2026, 03:58 PM
Last Post: b789
  Received a PCN from MET at Stansted (or Gatwick)? b789 0 782 01-22-2026, 03:42 PM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)