10-24-2026, 12:46 PM
The PPS evidence pack has now been reviewed, including the four-page landowner agreement. There are several significant deficiencies and omissions which warrant challenging before POPLA reaches its decision.
I suggest submitting the following rebuttal in response to the operator's evidence. It concentrates on the outstanding PoFA keeper-liability defects, the inadequacies of the landowner agreement, the absence of any specific arrangements for Amazon couriers and the unexplained circumstances surrounding the issuing of a postal NtK rather than a windscreen notice.
The PoFA arguments remain the most important. In particular, PPS cannot retrospectively correct a defective NtK by producing additional observation records, and its demand for payment must be scrutinised against the specific requirements of paragraph 9(2)(e).
Submit the rebuttal within POPLA's seven-day evidence-comment period. Do not identify the driver or add further details about the driver's activities.
I can't remember whether the POPLA website allows you to upload your response as an attachment (pdf). If not, just copy and paste the above text as is into their webform as it is within the character limit.
I suggest submitting the following rebuttal in response to the operator's evidence. It concentrates on the outstanding PoFA keeper-liability defects, the inadequacies of the landowner agreement, the absence of any specific arrangements for Amazon couriers and the unexplained circumstances surrounding the issuing of a postal NtK rather than a windscreen notice.
The PoFA arguments remain the most important. In particular, PPS cannot retrospectively correct a defective NtK by producing additional observation records, and its demand for payment must be scrutinised against the specific requirements of paragraph 9(2)(e).
Submit the rebuttal within POPLA's seven-day evidence-comment period. Do not identify the driver or add further details about the driver's activities.
Quote:APPELLANT'S COMMENTS ON THE OPERATOR'S EVIDENCE
The appellant maintains all grounds of the original appeal. These comments address specific deficiencies and admissions arising from PPS's evidence pack, particularly concerning statutory keeper liability, landowner authority and the arrangements governing temporary courier deliveries.
1. Failure to establish statutory keeper liability
PPS expressly acknowledges that its subsequent observation records do not alter the wording of the original Notice to Keeper. That admission is material.
Paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 to the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 requires the NtK itself to specify the period of parking. The original notice identifies no defined commencement time or duration, stating merely that the period was an unspecified interval immediately preceding the incident time of 20:29.
PPS now relies upon photographs taken between 20:22:02 and 20:28:52 and operative records allegedly extending from 20:21:53 to 20:29:22. Neither interval was specified in the NtK.
The existence of contemporaneous records is not the statutory question. The question is whether the notice served upon the keeper satisfied paragraph 9(2)(a). PPS has not demonstrated that it did.
The operator has similarly failed to address the opening requirement of paragraph 9(2)(e), namely the obligation to state that the creditor does not know both the name of the driver and a current address for service.
Failure to comply with PoFA Schedule 4, paragraph 9(2)(e)(i) — absence of the statutory invitation to pay
The appellant specifically challenges PPS's compliance with paragraph 9(2)(e)(i) of Schedule 4 to the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012. The provision expressly requires the creditor to invite the keeper "to pay the unpaid parking charges", as part of the statutory arrangements governing recovery from a registered keeper whose liability has not otherwise been established.
The NtK does not contain an invitation expressed in those terms. Instead, PPS states:
"We, the Creditor, now require this amount to be paid using one of the payment methods described overleaf."
The distinction between requiring and inviting payment is material. A requirement asserts an existing obligation to pay, whereas an invitation affords the recipient an opportunity to make payment without necessarily asserting that a personal legal liability has already arisen.
At the time the NtK was issued, PPS had not established that the registered keeper was the driver, nor had it demonstrated satisfaction of the statutory conditions necessary to transfer the driver's alleged liability to the keeper. An unqualified demand directed at the keeper therefore risks misrepresenting the recipient's legal position.
In its response to POPLA, PPS again relies upon the NtK's invitation to identify the driver, without addressing the separate objection concerning the language employed in demanding payment. The operator's reliance upon paragraph 9(2)(e)(ii) does not, of itself, establish that its payment demand satisfies the statutory language of paragraph 9(2)(e)(i).
The appellant acknowledges that the legislation employs the conjunction "or" between the alternative courses of action specified in subparagraphs (i) and (ii), and that the precise statutory wording need not necessarily be reproduced verbatim. The issue, however, is whether the NtK, construed as a whole, adequately conveys the statutory invitation rather than incorrectly asserting an unconditional obligation upon the keeper.
Furthermore, paragraph 9(2)(e) expressly requires the creditor to state that it does not know both the driver's name and a current address for service. PPS has not identified where that separate mandatory statement appears in the original notice. Its conditional warning about future keeper liability under paragraph 9(2)(f) does not necessarily satisfy that requirement.
The appellant therefore maintains that PPS has failed to demonstrate compliance with paragraph 9(2)(e) as a whole, including the particular statutory language of subparagraph (i).
These are not discretionary requirements which an assessor may simply dispense with because the operator has demonstrated an underlying permit contravention. Parliament made compliance with the applicable provisions of Schedule 4 a condition of the statutory entitlement to recover charges from the keeper.
The appellant requests that POPLA expressly determine whether PPS's unconditional demand for payment, considered alongside the absence of the required statement concerning the creditor's knowledge of the driver, satisfies paragraph 9(2)(e). The operator's general assertion of compliance is insufficient to resolve that question.
2. Incomplete evidence of landowner authority
The agreement submitted by PPS identifies Sutton Borough Conservative Federation as the contracting party. However, it does not establish whether that organisation was the proprietor, leaseholder or duly authorised managing agent entitled to appoint PPS.
Page 2 expressly requests supporting documentary evidence of the contracting party's authority over the premises. No such documentation appears in the four-page agreement.
Furthermore, page 1 expressly requires a site map defining the enforcement boundaries to be attached at page 4. The fourth page instead contains a list of regular car users and their registration numbers. It does not constitute the boundary map expressly requested by the agreement.
The appellant acknowledges that the document grants PPS general enforcement powers. However, the question remains whether PPS has adequately substantiated the contracting party's underlying authority and the precise geographical extent of the authorisation relied upon.
Any separately supplied site map must be examined to determine whether it identifies the contractual boundaries and corresponds with the landowner's authorisation.
3. Landowner arrangements concerning couriers and deliveries
The appellant's original appeal expressly challenged PPS's authority to enforce against a vehicle engaged in Amazon courier activity and required disclosure of the landowner's instructions concerning temporary deliveries.
PPS now asserts that its agreement provides no general exemption for commercial delivery drivers.
However, page 3 of the agreement contains a specific section requesting additional site-management instructions, including restrictions, permissions and relevant conditions. Those fields have been left blank.
Paragraph 14.1(e) of the applicable PPSCoP expressly requires written landowner authorisation covering relevant parking terms, including appropriate permissions and exemptions for persons stopping briefly, with delivery drivers and couriers specifically identified as examples.
The agreement contains no provision expressly addressing the treatment of genuine temporary deliveries, loading or unloading. Nor does PPS produce any site-specific operational instructions establishing how its attendants should distinguish ordinary parking from temporary courier activity.
It is not suggested that the Code automatically exempts all delivery drivers. Rather, the appellant submits that the contractual evidence does not satisfactorily establish how the landowner intended such activity to be regulated.
The contemporaneous Amazon block confirmation establishes that the vehicle was being used in connection with scheduled courier work during the relevant period. Although the document does not independently establish a delivery to Donnington House, it is relevant contextual evidence and must not be represented as having no evidential significance.
The appellant maintains the distinction identified in *Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd* between ordinary parking and temporary stopping for loading or unloading. PPS has not produced evidence resolving the landowner's intended treatment of that distinction at this location.
4. Identity of the operative and method of enforcement
The agreement states that PPS operatives may patrol the premises. However, the operator's evidence does not establish whether the individual who photographed the vehicle was directly employed by PPS or acted as a third-party self-ticketer.
That distinction matters because section 15.1 of the applicable PPSCoP imposes additional requirements where evidence is gathered by third parties, including registration, site auditing and quality assurance checks.
No Notice to Driver was served despite the operative allegedly observing the vehicle for more than seven minutes. The appellant accepts that a postal NtK may lawfully be issued without a preceding windscreen notice. Nevertheless, the circumstances do not establish the operative's status or demonstrate whether the applicable self-ticketing requirements were satisfied.
5. Conclusion
The operator's evidence has not remedied the original statutory challenges concerning paragraphs 9(2)(a) and 9(2)(e) of PoFA. Indeed, PPS expressly acknowledges that its supplementary observation records do not amend the original NtK.
The landowner agreement also contains material evidential gaps concerning the contracting party's authority, the required boundary documentation and the treatment of temporary deliveries and couriers.
The appellant requests that POPLA determine the statutory keeper-liability conditions first. If the NtK fails to satisfy either mandatory requirement, PPS cannot recover the charge from the registered keeper under Schedule 4, irrespective of whether it has established an underlying contravention by an unidentified driver.
The appellant respectfully requests that the appeal be allowed.
I can't remember whether the POPLA website allows you to upload your response as an attachment (pdf). If not, just copy and paste the above text as is into their webform as it is within the character limit.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain

