11-12-2026, 06:25 PM
@cringepcnskekw, as expected, P4Parking has rejected your appeal without properly addressing the fundamental failure of its Notice to Keeper (NtK) to comply with the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).
However, its rejection has revealed some useful additional information.
Firstly, P4Parking now claims that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds. That information was conspicuously absent from the original NtK, which specified only a single alleged contravention time of 13:32.
Paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 of PoFA expressly requires the NtK to specify the period of parking. The vague statement in the original notice that the period of parking immediately preceded the alleged contravention time does not satisfy that requirement. Providing an alleged duration in a subsequent appeal rejection cannot retrospectively remedy the defective NtK.
Secondly, P4Parking claims that the 14 minutes and 20 seconds exceeded an alleged 10-minute grace period. However, the consideration period and grace period are two distinct concepts under the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice. Simply asserting that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds does not establish that the driver accepted any contractual terms or that a parking contract was breached.
There is also an interesting inconsistency. The alleged contravention is "No valid digital permit", yet P4Parking refers to a 10-minute grace period displayed on its signage. We need to examine the actual signage to establish precisely what contractual terms it claims were breached.
Thirdly, we still have the potential argument arising from Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), which distinguishes genuine loading and unloading activities from parking. This could be particularly relevant given that the vehicle was being used for Amazon Flex deliveries, although evidence of the actual delivery activity would strengthen that argument considerably.
The next step is POPLA. Our primary argument will be that P4Parking has failed to establish keeper liability under PoFA. We can also challenge the alleged period of parking, the signage, and the operator's landowner authority.
Do not respond further to P4Parking.
Before I draft your POPLA appeal, please upload the remaining pages of the rejection, particularly any photographs of the signage or other evidence they have provided. These may reveal further weaknesses in their case.
When you upload photos, please use a higher resolution that the one you just provided as they are incredibly difficult to read properly.
You have 33 days (28 + 5 for service) from the issue of the POPLA code to submit your appeal, so there is no need to rush it. We want to ensure that every available appeal ground is properly addressed.
However, its rejection has revealed some useful additional information.
Firstly, P4Parking now claims that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds. That information was conspicuously absent from the original NtK, which specified only a single alleged contravention time of 13:32.
Paragraph 9(2)(a) of Schedule 4 of PoFA expressly requires the NtK to specify the period of parking. The vague statement in the original notice that the period of parking immediately preceded the alleged contravention time does not satisfy that requirement. Providing an alleged duration in a subsequent appeal rejection cannot retrospectively remedy the defective NtK.
Secondly, P4Parking claims that the 14 minutes and 20 seconds exceeded an alleged 10-minute grace period. However, the consideration period and grace period are two distinct concepts under the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice. Simply asserting that the vehicle was observed for 14 minutes and 20 seconds does not establish that the driver accepted any contractual terms or that a parking contract was breached.
There is also an interesting inconsistency. The alleged contravention is "No valid digital permit", yet P4Parking refers to a 10-minute grace period displayed on its signage. We need to examine the actual signage to establish precisely what contractual terms it claims were breached.
Thirdly, we still have the potential argument arising from Jopson v Homeguard Services Ltd (2016), which distinguishes genuine loading and unloading activities from parking. This could be particularly relevant given that the vehicle was being used for Amazon Flex deliveries, although evidence of the actual delivery activity would strengthen that argument considerably.
The next step is POPLA. Our primary argument will be that P4Parking has failed to establish keeper liability under PoFA. We can also challenge the alleged period of parking, the signage, and the operator's landowner authority.
Do not respond further to P4Parking.
Before I draft your POPLA appeal, please upload the remaining pages of the rejection, particularly any photographs of the signage or other evidence they have provided. These may reveal further weaknesses in their case.
When you upload photos, please use a higher resolution that the one you just provided as they are incredibly difficult to read properly.
You have 33 days (28 + 5 for service) from the issue of the POPLA code to submit your appeal, so there is no need to rush it. We want to ensure that every available appeal ground is properly addressed.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain

