Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Horizon Parking Parent & Child Bay PA
#1
Hi, 

Need some assistance with regards to Parent and Child bay parking at Tesco. I received this particular ticket  for the first time and before appealing wanted some guidance. I did park in parent & child bay and the baby was with in the car with my partner. I only ran get to pick up the milk. Any suggestion / guidance would be appreciated.


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   
#2
Welcome to the forum @Ali. You have good grounds to challenge this PCN. Parent and Child bays are intended for motorists travelling with young children, and you have confirmed that a baby was present in the vehicle, accompanied by one parent, while the other briefly entered Tesco to purchase milk. That does not, in itself, establish any breach of the parking conditions.

However, the precise conditions governing the use of these bays depend on the wording of the signs. Unless the signage expressly requires the child to accompany an adult into the store, there is no obvious contractual basis for insisting that the baby must leave the vehicle. Horizon would need to demonstrate which clearly displayed parking condition was breached and how the circumstances amounted to that breach. The question is not whether the baby entered Tesco, but whether the vehicle was parked in breach of any clearly communicated contractual condition.

There is also a potential issue with keeper liability. From the front of the Notice to Keeper (NtK), Horizon does not appear to be relying on the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA) to transfer liability from the driver to the registered keeper. However, I need to see the reverse of the NtK before confirming whether it complies with PoFA. If Horizon has failed to comply with the statutory requirements, it cannot hold the registered keeper liable for the driver's alleged parking charge.

In the meantime, Plan A should be a complaint directly to Tesco, preferably to the store manager or Tesco's customer services, explaining that a baby was present in the vehicle with one parent while the other briefly entered the store to purchase milk. The vehicle was therefore being used by a family with a young child, which is precisely the category of customer these bays are intended to accommodate.

Tesco is Horizon's principal, or at least the retailer on whose premises Horizon operates, and should be asked to intervene and arrange cancellation of the charge. Do not accept being fobbed off with instructions to appeal directly to Horizon. The purpose of contacting Tesco is to seek cancellation as a customer complaint, independently of Horizon's appeals process.

If the store manager claims they have no authority to cancel parking charges, ask for the complaint to be escalated to whoever manages the parking arrangements or has authority to instruct Horizon. Explain that penalising a genuine customer for using a Parent and Child bay while accompanied by a baby is unreasonable, particularly when no evidence has been provided of any actual misuse of the bay.

If you have a receipt or other evidence of the Tesco purchase, include it with the complaint. However, do not identify the driver or make any unnecessary admissions about who parked the vehicle.

Please upload a photograph of the back of the NtK and, if possible, the signage governing the Parent and Child bays. We can then establish the strongest grounds for an appeal to Horizon if Tesco fails to cancel it.

[/b]Do not identify the driver[/b], either here or in any correspondence with Horizon.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#3
Hi @b789 Much appreciated. I will certainly go to Tesco tomorrow and will update their response. In the meanwhile, I have attached the second page of the parking charge.


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   
#4
@Ali. thanks for uploading the reverse of the NtK. This confirms that Horizon has failed to comply with the requirements of Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).

In particular, the mandatory warning required by paragraph 9(2)(f) is missing. Horizon refers to recovering the charge from the driver but makes no provision for transferring liability to the registered keeper. Consequently, Horizon cannot hold you liable as the Keeper, and you are under no obligation to identify the driver.

This gives us a straightforward appeal point, regardless of the circumstances surrounding the use of the Parent and Child bay.

However, continue with Plan A and approach Tesco tomorrow. Explain the circumstances and ask the manager to arrange cancellation. There is no reason to get involved in a dispute with Horizon if Tesco can resolve the matter directly.

Please let us know Tesco's response. If they refuse to intervene, we can submit a short keeper appeal to Horizon based on its failure to comply with PoFA. If Horizon rejects that appeal, we can take the matter to POPLA, where the absence of keeper liability should be decisive, provided the driver's identity has not been disclosed.

[/b]Under no circumstances identify the driver[/b], either to Tesco or Horizon.

There is a further breach of the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice (PPSCoP). Horizon incorrectly states that an appeal must be received within 28 days of the date of the Parking Charge. However, paragraph 8.1.2(e) of the PPSSCoP expressly recognises the 28-day appeal period as running from receipt of the notice, not its issue date.

Horizon is therefore attempting to shorten the period available to the recipient by the time taken for postal delivery. This is another Code compliance issue that can be raised in a complaint to the BPA.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#5
Hi @b789,

Thank you for your support so far.

I visited Tesco today and spoke to the duty manager. Initially, she said that Tesco could not get involved in the matter. However, when I explained that, as a Tesco customer, I wanted to raise an official complaint, she said she would ask someone to send an email to Horizon.

I also asked whether she could provide written confirmation of this, but she said she was unable to provide anything in writing. As a result, I am still uncertain whether Tesco will actually contact Horizon and follow up on the matter.

While I was at Tesco, I also took photographs of the signage for reference, which I have attached. Nowhere it mentions that child needs to go in the supermarket. Look forward to your guidance for next steps.


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   
#6
@Ali, Thanks for the update and the photograph of the signage.

The wording of the sign is particularly helpful. It states that a parking charge may be issued for:

"Parking in a parent and child bay unaccompanied by young children."

There is no requirement for the child to enter Tesco, accompany the adult doing the shopping, or even leave the vehicle. You have explained that a baby was present in the vehicle with one parent while the other briefly entered the store.

On the ordinary meaning of the displayed condition, there was no breach. The vehicle was being used by a family accompanied by a young child, precisely the circumstances for which these bays are provided. Horizon cannot simply impose additional conditions that are not communicated on the signage.

Regarding Tesco, it is disappointing that the duty manager was initially unwilling to intervene. Her subsequent assurance that someone would email Horizon is encouraging, but without written confirmation, we cannot assume anything has been done.

Given the unsatisfactory response from the duty manager, I would now recommend making a formal written complaint directly to Tesco's Group Chief Executive, Ken Murphy, rather than pursuing the matter through ordinary customer services.

His email address is:

ken.murphy@tesco.com

Explain that you were a genuine Tesco customer, that a baby was present in the vehicle with one parent while the other briefly entered the store, and that Horizon has issued a £70 parking charge despite the circumstances complying with the conditions displayed on Tesco's signage.

Point out that the signage prohibits parking in a Parent and Child bay "unaccompanied by young children". It does not require the child to enter the store or leave the vehicle.

Also explain that you approached the duty manager, who initially refused to intervene but subsequently suggested someone might contact Horizon. Unfortunately, she would not provide written confirmation that any action would be taken.

Ask Mr Murphy to have his executive complaints team investigate and instruct Horizon to cancel the parking charge, with written confirmation of cancellation.

Attach a copy of the parking charge notice and the photograph of the signage. If available, include evidence of the Tesco purchase.

This is a complaint about the treatment of a genuine customer and the conduct of Tesco's parking contractor, not an appeal to Horizon.

In the meantime, we retain the separate and decisive keeper liability argument under PoFA should an appeal to Horizon become necessary. Do not identify the driver, and do not allow the Tesco complaint to interfere with the deadline for appealing to Horizon.

One final point: If Tesco has not confirmed cancellation, please return to this thread at least five days before the 28-day appeal deadline and remind me that we need to submit an appeal to Horizon.

We must submit the keeper appeal to Horizon before that deadline expires, regardless of whether Tesco has responded to the complaint. We will rely on Horizon's failure to comply with PoFA and will not identify the driver. Do not wait for a response from Tesco if doing so risks missing the appeal deadline.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#7
(11-16-2026, 11:01 PM)Ali Wrote: Hi @b789,

Thank you for your support so far.

I visited Tesco today and spoke to the duty manager. Initially, she said that Tesco could not get involved in the matter. 

The suggestion that a landowner can appoint a parking operator, authorise it to act on its land, benefit from the arrangement, and then claim to be unable to intervene when disputes arise is not a particularly credible one. 

A principal cannot simply outsource enforcement and simultaneously outsource accountability.  The distinction appears to be not that the landowner cannot get involved, but that it has chosen not to. 

That distinction may prove rather more significant than the landowner seems willing to acknowledge.

In short: if the landowner has sufficient authority to appoint the parking company, it is impossible to argue that it has no authority whatsoever over the consequences of that appointment.

Tesco are shafting you.
#8
Simply ask who is the Organ Grinder and who is the Monkey in the contractual relationship between Tesco and Horizon.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#9
Hi @b789,

Shall I send an appeal to Horizon now, just in case the appeal decision doesn't go in my favour, to prevent the £40 fine increasing to £70? Shall i just mention the there is no requirement for the child to enter Tesco, accompany the adult doing the shopping, or even leave the vehicle hence no breach? I will just write registered keeper as my name?

Previously, when it has been my fault, i have just paid the fine but this time do not believe I should pay.
#10
@Ali, first, it is not a "fine". Private parking companies have no authority to issue fines or penalties. This is simply a speculative invoice alleging a breach of contract by an unknown driver, which Horizon would ultimately have to prove in court if it wanted to enforce payment.

The £40 reduced amount is what is known as the "mugs discount". It is designed to encourage motorists to pay up quickly rather than question whether they owe anything. The threat of the charge increasing to £70 creates an incentive to pay, even when there are perfectly valid grounds for challenging it.

As for appealing now, I would stick with Plan A and give Tesco the opportunity to cancel it first, provided we do not miss the appeal deadline. There is no advantage in rushing to appeal simply to preserve the discounted amount when we have strong grounds for disputing liability altogether.

Don't expect Horizon to accept an initial appeal, regardless of how compelling the evidence might be. These private parking firms are not in the business of dispensing justice or treating motorists fairly; they are in the business of extracting money from them. Every appeal they uphold is another potential payment lost, so there is an obvious financial incentive to reject appeals, however meritorious, and hope that motorists will simply give up and pay.

The entire business model relies heavily on motorists being intimidated by official-looking demands, threats of escalating charges and the prospect of court proceedings. There is plenty of low-hanging fruit on the gullible tree. Why cancel a charge when you can reject the appeal with a template letter and hope the motorist caves in? That is why we have POPLA, where an independent assessor can consider the appeal without the operator having the final say. Even then, POPLA is far from infallible.

Importantly, we have a stronger argument than the Parent and Child bay issue alone. Horizon's NtK fails to comply with PoFA, meaning it cannot transfer liability to the registered keeper. There is no need to identify the driver or discuss what the driver did in the keeper appeal.

When the time comes, the appeal must be submitted in your own name, expressly as the registered keeper, not simply under the name "Registered Keeper".

For now, pursue the complaint to Tesco's CEO and remind me at least five days before the 28-day appeal deadline, calculated from receipt of the NtK. If Tesco has not confirmed cancellation, we will submit the keeper appeal to Horizon before that deadline expires.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Horizon Parking PCN Tortfeasor 26 3,429 11-16-2026, 11:01 PM
Last Post: Tortfeasor
  Horizon Parking/Gladstones – Claim Struck Out – Defective PoC – CPR 16.4 and PD 16 b789 0 125 11-14-2026, 09:42 PM
Last Post: b789
  Parent and Child PCN Amplitoad 2 242 11-10-2026, 07:14 PM
Last Post: b789
  Horizon Parking beaten at Holyhead Ferry Terminal b789 4 502 10-19-2026, 02:46 PM
Last Post: b789
  Horizon parking (Double dip) Foxy01 9 1,642 09-16-2026, 01:06 PM
Last Post: b789
  Horizon Claim mouse 55 11,454 09-11-2026, 02:57 PM
Last Post: mouse
  Parking Group - The Parking People parking fine James53436 1 984 05-17-2026, 07:55 PM
Last Post: b789
  ANPR - Horizon Parking - Hotel Nelson Norwich candlestick 11 4,721 04-22-2026, 03:06 PM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)