Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Horizon Parking/Gladstones – Claim Struck Out – Defective PoC – CPR 16.4 and PD 16
#1
Horizon Parking / Gladstones – Claim Struck Out – Defective Particulars of Claim

County Court at Peterborough – District Judge Evans – 16 October 2026

Outcome: CLAIM STRUCK OUT – NO LIABILITY – NO CCJ

This is a reconstructed history of a case involving @Gooner, who received a County Court claim from Horizon Parking Ltd, represented by Gladstones Solicitors, concerning an alleged parking contravention at Travelodge Cambridge, Newmarket Road.

The original advice thread was accidentally deleted, but I continued assisting @Gooner throughout the proceedings. Now that the final judgment has been received, I thought it worthwhile documenting the case, particularly because of the Judge's detailed reasons for striking out the claim.

It demonstrates why inadequate Particulars of Claim (PoC) should be challenged from the outset, why a Claimant cannot simply rely upon a subsequent witness statement to explain what should have been pleaded, and why defendants should not assume that a professionally represented parking company will automatically be permitted to disregard the Civil Procedure Rules.

Background – The original PCN

The alleged parking event occurred on 1 November 2023 at Travelodge Cambridge, Newmarket Road.

Horizon alleged that the vehicle had remained in the car park between approximately 03:44 and 10:32 without paying or registering for the full duration of the stay. A Parking Charge Notice (PCN) demanding £85 was subsequently issued.

@Gooner was the registered keeper. His recollection was that the vehicle had been associated with a genuine, paid hotel stay and that parking was believed to have been included or paid for.

The Notice to Keeper (NtK) did not invoke Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA) or expressly seek to transfer liability from the driver to the keeper.

However, the eventual Defence was deliberately concentrated on the fundamental defects in Gladstones' PoC, rather than attempting to answer allegations that had not been properly pleaded.

June–July 2025 – The claim and Defence

The claim was issued on 11 June 2025.

@Gooner acknowledged service on 16 June and sought advice because the PoC appeared vague and provided little meaningful explanation of the alleged contractual breach.

On reviewing the claim, I advised that Gladstones had failed to plead a properly comprehensible cause of action. The Defence was therefore drafted principally around CPR 16.4(1)(a) and Practice Direction 16.

The central objection was that the PoC failed to identify the specific contractual terms allegedly breached, what conduct constituted that breach, the basis upon which @Gooner was allegedly liable, and how the amount claimed had been calculated.

The Defence relied upon the persuasive County Court appeal decisions in:

• Civil Enforcement Ltd v Chan (2023), Claim No. E7GM9W44.
• Car Park Management Service Ltd v Akande (2024), Claim No. K0DP5J30.

Both decisions concerned inadequately pleaded private parking claims.

A draft strike-out order and transcripts of those decisions accompanied the Defence.

The Defence was emailed to CNBC on 3 July 2025. Unfortunately, administrative problems at CNBC meant that although @Gooner received the automated acknowledgement, the Defence was not initially recorded as processed.

Following further enquiries, it was resent on 14 July.


.pdf   @Gooner Defence.pdf (Size: 46.62 KB / Downloads: 0)

On 26 July, @Gooner received written confirmation from CNBC that the Defence had been received and would be sent to the Claimant.

This became particularly significant later, when Gladstones claimed in their witness statement that they had not received the Defence.

September–November 2025 – Directions and mediation

On 1 September 2025, the stay was lifted and Directions Questionnaires were issued.

The case subsequently proceeded to telephone mediation on 5 November 2025.

@Gooner maintained that liability was denied and offered £0 in settlement.

The Claimant's representative, who identified herself only as Olivia, reportedly declined to provide her surname or position. More significantly, according to @Gooner, the mediator confirmed that the Claimant's representative had not seen the Defence.

The Claimant's lowest settlement figure was reportedly £230.

No settlement was reached.

This was particularly concerning because the Defence had already been processed by CNBC and the proceedings were progressing normally as a defended claim.

March–May 2026 – Transfer and allocation

In March 2026, @Gooner received notice that the proceedings had been transferred to his local County Court.

The Notice of Allocation, dated 6 May 2026, listed the hearing for 17 July 2026 at Peterborough County Court.

The court ordered witness statements to be exchanged by 3 June 2026.

It also ordered Horizon to pay the £27 trial fee by 4pm on 19 June 2026, expressly providing that failure to do so would result in the claim being struck out with effect from that date, without further order. The Claimant would also be liable for @Gooner's costs unless the court ordered otherwise.

June 2026 – The witness statement debacle

@Gooner prepared and served his witness statement within the court's deadline.

The statement was deliberately restricted to matters within his knowledge and the issues already raised in the Defence. It explained that the generic PoC had left him unable to understand precisely what contractual breach Horizon alleged.

The statement also referred to Liberty Homes (Kent) Ltd v Rajakanthan & Ors [2022] EWHC 2201 (TCC), concerning the requirement to identify the nature of the agreement relied upon.

Gladstones failed to serve their witness statement by the deadline.

Their statement eventually arrived on 5 June 2026 at 13:43, almost two days late and after they had received @Gooner's statement.

It was signed by Elise Davies, a solicitor employed by Gladstones, rather than anyone from Horizon with direct knowledge of the alleged parking event.

The document contained several remarkable defects.

First, paragraph 2 stated that the hearing was listed for 19 June 2026 at Burnley County Court. The actual hearing was scheduled for 17 July 2026 at Peterborough County Court.

Second, Gladstones claimed that they had not been served with the Defence, despite CNBC having confirmed its receipt and onward service in July 2025, followed by Directions Questionnaires, mediation and allocation.

Third, their exhibits included apparently generic signage material and photographs dated months before the alleged parking event. Questions also arose concerning the completeness of payment records and the reliability of the photographic evidence.

However, the most revealing statement appeared at paragraph 17:

"The Claimant's case is now fully particularised within this Witness Statement."

That was precisely the problem.

The Claimant was attempting to provide, through a late witness statement, the factual case that should have appeared in the original PoC.

A witness statement is evidence, not a substitute for properly pleaded Particulars of Claim.

@Gooner submitted a written objection to the late statement, highlighting the procedural prejudice and requesting that it be excluded or that he be permitted to respond to any newly introduced matters.

June 2026 – The late hearing fee

The next procedural failure concerned the hearing fee.

The Notice of Allocation expressly required Horizon to pay £27 by 4pm on 19 June 2026, failing which the claim would be struck out without further order.

Following the deadline, @Gooner contacted the court and was advised that no payment had been recorded.

He consequently requested confirmation that the automatic strike-out had taken effect and submitted a costs schedule.

However, subsequent enquiries established that Horizon had paid the hearing fee on 25 June 2026, six days late.

Despite the unequivocal wording of the allocation order, the court continued to list the hearing.

@Gooner raised this issue in written submissions, relying upon CPR 3.8 and the absence of any application for relief from sanction served upon him.

The court subsequently indicated that a District Judge would review the matters raised concerning the late witness statement and request for directions.

July–October 2026 – Adjournment and final hearing

The hearing scheduled for 17 July 2026 was adjourned at the last minute because of judicial unavailability.

It was subsequently relisted for 16 October 2026.

Unfortunately, @Gooner was unable to attend because of an ongoing family issue. He therefore submitted a notice under CPR 27.9 asking the court to determine the claim in his absence.

Gladstones also notified him on 2 October that Horizon would not be attending and had asked the court to decide the case under CPR 27.9.

Because there was a risk that Gladstones' trial bundle would omit important documents, @Gooner prepared and submitted his own complete, indexed, 89-page bundle.

This contained the Defence, witness statement, relevant exhibits, objections to Gladstones' late evidence, written submissions, court orders, correspondence concerning the late hearing fee and costs schedule.

The written submissions emphasised the defective PoC, the procedural failures, the absence of an application for relief from sanction and the overriding objective.

Neither party attended the hearing on 16 October 2026. The Judge considered the matter on the written evidence and submissions.

The HMCTS delay – Almost four weeks of uncertainty

Unfortunately, the conclusion of the hearing did not end @Gooner's difficulties.

Despite repeated telephone enquiries and urgent emails, HMCTS could not confirm whether the claim had succeeded, been dismissed or whether judgment had been reserved.

He was even advised that the order could take up to 11 weeks to be issued.

This was particularly concerning because an adverse judgment dated 16 October could have required payment in full by 16 November to secure cancellation of its registration and avoid any lasting adverse entry on his credit record.

The uncertainty caused considerable anxiety.

Urgent correspondence was sent to the Peterborough Court Manager and a formal complaint was submitted to HMCTS.

Gladstones subsequently confirmed that they had not received the court's order either.

Eventually, on 12 November, @Gooner received the judgment by post.


.pdf   Gladstones Order-compressed.pdf (Size: 238.88 KB / Downloads: 0)

Horizon Parking's claim had been struck out in its entirety.

The judgment – District Judge Evans

The General Form of Judgment or Order was issued on 10 November 2026, recording the decision made on 16 October 2026.

The operative order states:

1. The claim is struck out.

2. There is no order as to costs.

More importantly, District Judge Evans provided detailed written reasons explaining why the claim could not succeed.

At paragraph 6, the Judge found that the Claimant's PoC failed to comply with the mandatory requirements of CPR 16.4(1)(a).

At paragraph 7, the Judge referred specifically to Practice Direction 16 paragraph 7.3, requiring the conduct relied upon to be identified where a contractual agreement is alleged to have been breached by conduct.

Paragraph 8 is particularly significant:

"There are many ways in which a contract such as that relied upon by the Claimant may be breached and it should not be for the Defendant to have to guess which of them, or how many of them may be said to apply;"

The Judge also acknowledged that @Gooner had explained that the vehicle was associated with a genuine hotel stay and that he understood parking had been paid for.

Had the allegations been properly pleaded, those matters could have been investigated and addressed. However, the Claimant's failure to identify the actual alleged breach had prevented a meaningful response.

The Judge's criticism of the Claimant's business model

Paragraph 11 is particularly telling:

"The Claimant could have served separate and properly pleaded Particulars of Claim. That appears to lie outwith its business model, and there is no application to amend;"

That observation goes directly to the practice of issuing large numbers of claims supported by generic, template PoC.

At paragraphs 12–14, the Judge concluded that the Particulars were defective, the proceedings had nevertheless continued, and there had been a serious procedural failure without any application for relief from sanction.

The final paragraph states:

"Even if there had been, the failure to comply is serious; there is no good reason for it, and taking all the circumstances into account the claim is struck out."

The judgment does not expressly identify the late hearing fee as the determining reason for strike-out. The Judge's reasoning concentrates principally on the defective pleadings and procedural non-compliance.

Conclusion – Why this case matters

This was a complete victory for @Gooner, achieved despite his inability to attend the final hearing.

The judgment substantially vindicated the original Defence, which challenged Gladstones' failure to plead a comprehensible cause of action under CPR 16.4 and PD 16.

There are several important lessons from this case.

Firstly, the responsibility for pleading a proper cause of action rests with the Claimant. A defendant should not be expected to guess what contractual term was allegedly breached or how the alleged breach occurred.

Secondly, a subsequent witness statement is not a substitute for properly particularised PoC. Claimants should not assume that they can issue vague allegations and explain the actual case months later through witness evidence.

Thirdly, professionally represented serial litigants are subject to the same Civil Procedure Rules as everyone else. The Judge's comments concerning Horizon's apparent business model are particularly noteworthy.

Finally, this case demonstrates the importance of ensuring that the court has all relevant evidence and written submissions, especially where attendance is not possible and the matter must be determined under CPR 27.9.

District Judge Evans's judgment is not a binding precedent, but it is a reasoned County Court decision which may be persuasive in other cases involving similarly defective private parking claims.

The most useful passages are paragraphs 6–8 and 11–14.

I will attach a suitably redacted copy of the original Defence, the Claimant's witness statement and the final two-page judgment.

Final outcome: CLAIM STRUCK OUT – NO LIABILITY – NO CCJ.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Horizon Parking Parent & Child Bay PA Ali 12 573 11-19-2026, 05:33 PM
Last Post: Brenda_R2
  Horizon Parking PCN Tortfeasor 26 3,528 11-16-2026, 11:01 PM
Last Post: Tortfeasor
  Gladstones Claim Form therealrjp 15 1,941 10-26-2026, 10:42 AM
Last Post: b789
  LBC - Private Parking Solutions - Gladstones pcnappeal 7 950 10-20-2026, 09:43 AM
Last Post: pcnappeal
  Horizon Parking beaten at Holyhead Ferry Terminal b789 4 527 10-19-2026, 02:46 PM
Last Post: b789
  Claim form received from two alleged contraventions 3 years ago - SMART PARKING JoeBloggs90 21 4,951 10-13-2026, 02:13 PM
Last Post: b789
  Gladstones Letter Before Claim - NPM PCN - No e-Permit - Woodgrange Road E7 armz247 9 2,017 09-19-2026, 09:07 AM
Last Post: b789
  Horizon parking (Double dip) Foxy01 9 1,681 09-16-2026, 01:06 PM
Last Post: b789
  Horizon Claim mouse 55 11,692 09-11-2026, 02:57 PM
Last Post: mouse
  3 private parking tickets being pursued for all 3 and had a ccj claim made Barbudaprince 54 14,920 09-02-2026, 11:28 AM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: Gooner, 1 Guest(s)