Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
PCN ASDA BATLEY - Parkingeye Advice Needed
#1
Hi,

Hope you’re well. I’m new here and have heard many great things about this forum! I would appreciate your advice on how best to proceed with a parking fine I’ve received.

Thanks  Smile


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
       
#2
ParkingEye's paperwork is generally the benchmark that other operators try to copy.

They lost enough cases in the early days of POFA that their legal team largely standardised the wording years ago.

My first move would not be a legal POFA attack because it will probably fail. It would be:
  • Complain to the Asda store manager and request they instruct ParkingEye to cancel
  • If unsuccessful, escalate to Asda customer services HO
  • Produce receipts/bank transactions if any shopping took place

That's often far more effective than technical arguments with ParkingEye.

But wait for @b789 to comment - he has infinitely more expertise in this area than me and may have a different take.
#3
Welcome to the forum, @Naj458.

@Brenda_R2 is essentially correct. ParkingEye (PE) has finally corrected the longstanding defect in its Notices to Keeper (NtKs), which previously failed to comply with paragraph 9(2)(e)(i) of Schedule 4 to the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 (PoFA).

Following its defeat in ParkingEye v Ganash last year, PE has now added the remarkably simple sentence:

"...or alternatively, you as the Registered Keeper, are invited to pay the Parking Charge."

That was all that was required to address this particular defect, which PE had stubbornly failed to correct for years. Unfortunately, it means that the previously successful PoFA argument is no longer available against this particular NtK.

However, that certainly does not mean the charge is automatically enforceable or that you should pay it.

It is also important to understand that this is not a "fine" or penalty imposed by any statutory authority. ParkingEye is a private company with no authority to issue fines. What you have received is simply a speculative invoice alleging that the driver, whose identity is unknown to PE, breached the terms of a purported parking contract.

PE is attempting to recover that alleged contractual charge from you as the Registered Keeper by relying on PoFA. However, compliance with PoFA does not automatically establish that a valid contract existed, that its terms were breached or that the charge is enforceable. It merely provides a statutory mechanism through which PE may hold the Keeper liable for a charge that would otherwise be recoverable from the driver, provided all the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied.

From what we know so far, the vehicle allegedly exceeded the maximum permitted stay of two hours at Asda Batley by 15 minutes. Before advising on the best approach, we need a little more context.

Was the driver or any passenger a customer of Asda during that visit? If so, is there any evidence of purchases, such as a receipt, bank statement or transaction in the Asda app?

There are four plans of action you should follow, always in this order:

Plan A – Landowner cancellation. Complain directly to Asda and ask for the charge to be cancelled. The landowner, or whoever has authority over the car park, is ultimately responsible for contracting ParkingEye (PE) to manage it. A genuine customer complaint, particularly supported by evidence of purchases, is often the most effective route.

Plan B – Appeal to the operator. If Plan A fails, submit an appeal directly to ParkingEye. We will advise on the wording once we have the necessary background. Importantly, any appeal should be made only as the Registered Keeper, without identifying the driver.

Plan C – Independent appeals service. If PE rejects the appeal, it should issue a POPLA verification code. POPLA is the supposedly "independent" appeals service used by operators belonging to the British Parking Association (BPA). We can then consider whether there are sufficiently strong grounds for a POPLA appeal.

Plan D – County Court. If all else fails, there is no obligation to pay merely because PE or POPLA rejects an appeal. The remaining course is to wait and see whether PE decides to issue a court claim. If it does, the claim can be defended. Ultimately, a County Court judge, rather than PE or its industry's appeals service, is the genuinely independent arbiter who determines whether any enforceable debt exists.

For now, concentrate on Plan A and answer the question about whether anyone in the vehicle was an Asda customer. There is no need to rush into an appeal to PE before we establish the circumstances.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#4
Hello again, and thanks for the detailed response @b789 and warm welcome! Thanks also to @Brenda_R2 for your help with this, I really appreciate it.

Unfortunately, there was no visit to Asda. The car was parked there in order to visit a restaurant nearby. The Tesco opposite has shared parking for several other shops, so the driver assumed it would be fine to park at Asda as well, without realising how long they’d be there or that it could result in a fine. No Asda customer.
#5
(10-31-2026, 12:46 PM)Naj458 Wrote: Hello again, and thanks for the detailed response @b789 and warm welcome! Thanks also to @Brenda_R2 for your help with this, I really appreciate it.

Unfortunately, there was no visit to Asda. The car was parked there in order to visit a restaurant nearby. The Tesco opposite has shared parking for several other shops, so the driver assumed it would be fine to park at Asda as well, without realising how long they’d be there or that it could result in a fine. No Asda customer.

Let me see if I've understood this correctly.

Your defence is:

"I wasn't an Asda customer, I had no intention of being an Asda customer, I parked on Asda's land for three hours while spending money somewhere else, I didn't check the signs, and I just assumed the rules didn't apply because Tesco has a different arrangement."

That's not a defence. That's practically the parking company's witness statement.

You've essentially confessed to every element of their claim and then added helpful context.

Imagine standing before a judge and saying:

"I didn't buy a ticket for the train because the bus company across the road lets people travel without one."

That's the level of legal firepower we're working with here.

Private parking cases are won by identifying failures in signage, contractual wording, landowner authority, POFA compliance, grace periods, evidence deficiencies, or procedural errors.

They're generally not won by:

"Yes, I did exactly what they say I did, but I mistakenly thought someone else's car park worked the same way."

At the moment your appeal appears to consist of a detailed explanation of why the charge was correctly issued.

If you want help, learned members  of this forum can certainly look for technical or legal arguments. But as a defence, "I parked in Asda for three hours while visiting a restaurant and wasn't an Asda customer" is roughly equivalent to contesting a speeding ticket with "I was doing 50 in a 30 but thought the limit was only advisory."

Pay the PCN before the charge escalates massively.
#6
Thanks for clarifying, @Naj458. Unfortunately, that changes matters considerably. As nobody was visiting Asda, there is little realistic prospect of obtaining a cancellation through Plan A.

The vehicle remained in the car park for approximately 2 hours and 15 minutes, exceeding the advertised two-hour maximum stay. The applicable industry Code provides a 10-minute grace period, but that does not excuse the full 15 minutes. Nor can the separate consideration period simply be added to the permitted parking time.

There is also the Supreme Court judgment in ParkingEye Ltd v Beavis [2015] UKSC 67, which upheld the enforceability of a private parking charge arising from an overstay in a retail car park offering two hours of free parking.

However, that does not mean ParkingEye automatically has an enforceable claim. The one potentially significant issue we have not yet established is whether the signage was adequate to bring the contractual terms to the driver's attention.

Do you have, or can you obtain, photographs of the signage at the Asda car park, particularly the entrance sign and the signs displaying the parking terms and conditions? We need to establish whether the two-hour restriction and the £100 parking charge were prominently and clearly communicated, whether parking is expressly restricted to Asda customers only or is available to other visitors, and whether the signs were sufficiently visible and legible for a driver to understand the contractual terms before accepting them.

ParkingEye cannot simply rely on ANPR photographs and an allegation of overstaying. It must establish that a contractual agreement was formed, that the relevant terms were adequately communicated and that those terms were breached. If the signage was inadequate, that could provide grounds for challenging the charge, notwithstanding the decision in Beavis.

There is some urgency, however. Your NtK was issued on 22 October 2026. Under the Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice, an appeal made while the discounted payment rate remains available preserves that rate for a further 14 days following notification of rejection. For safety, we should work towards 4 November 2026 as the deadline for submitting an initial appeal if you wish to preserve the £60 option.

I would therefore suggest obtaining photographs of the signage as soon as possible so that we can assess whether there are grounds for a properly formulated initial appeal to ParkingEye. Any appeal must be submitted solely as the Registered Keeper, without identifying the driver.

If PE rejects that appeal, we can consider whether the signage or any other evidence provides sufficiently strong grounds to proceed to POPLA. However, a POPLA appeal would mean forfeiting the discounted payment opportunity, so that decision should be made with a realistic assessment of the prospects of success.

If the signage proves adequate and there are no other relevant circumstances, paying the discounted £60 may ultimately be the most pragmatic decision. I would rather give you a realistic assessment than encourage you to pursue a weak case simply on principle.

Finally, a word of advice for the future. Whenever parking on private land, ALWAYS assume that restrictions apply and actively look for and read the signs before leaving the vehicle unattended. Never assume that because parking is free, or because nearby shops share parking facilities, the same arrangements apply elsewhere. Different car parks can have entirely different contractual terms, including customer-only restrictions, maximum stays and permit requirements. A few moments checking the signage can avoid a great deal of unnecessary expense and aggravation.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain
#7
Thanks for getting back to me. I thought in the end it was just best to pay it and get it out the way. Thanks both @b789 @Brenda_R2
#8
@Naj458, yes, that was probably the best option as there was unlikely to be much chance of beating this unless there was an obvious signage issue. If the driver genuinely didn't know that there were parking restrictions in place because of inadequate signage, that would have been the only likely avenue to dispute the charge.

At least it has been paid within the discount period.
Never argue with stupid people. They will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. - Mark Twain


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  PCN Manchester Airport - APCOA Parking Advice Needed Naj458 5 42 Yesterday, 10:31 PM
Last Post: b789
  Chalon Way West Retail Park - ParkingEye billnit 9 1,040 10-09-2026, 03:14 PM
Last Post: billnit
  Advice needed - no permit provided, ticketed while parked in allocated space. KHarHar 11 1,714 09-14-2026, 03:27 PM
Last Post: b789
  UKPC PCN while delivering for Amazon Flex – POPLA advice needed ibadusaf 7 1,959 08-08-2026, 04:04 PM
Last Post: b789
  Help needed with Civil Enforcement Ltd CCJ claim Arbitration 8 2,452 06-13-2026, 03:07 PM
Last Post: b789
  ParkingEye - parked over time - Lidl, London sinaloa 7 2,791 04-14-2026, 03:43 PM
Last Post: b789
  Parkingeye PCN: Passey Place Car Park - Ticket Not Purchased! Eryobotrya 10 3,388 03-29-2026, 06:32 PM
Last Post: Eryobotrya
Information ParkingEye, Harrow Hall, Langley b789 1 1,072 01-24-2026, 10:24 AM
Last Post: b789

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)